David Sherman's recent Toronto Star article framing the recent closure of the free Montréal English-language weekly the
Montreal Mirror in terms of existential problems for media in the Anglophone community in Canada's second-largest city surprises me.
Anglophones in Québec amount, depending on the definition, to nearly eight hundred thousand people, with the Anglophone population of Montréal proper accounting for three-quarters of that. Surely that's a large enough of a population to sustain a weekly--Ottawa does it with a similar total, right?
The
editorial in Montréal English-language weekly
The Suburban suggesting that better business models and owners than most of the closed-down media had would have saved them makes a lot of sense.
The city’s English media is dying a protracted and painful death.
This month, the closure of the all-sports radio station TSN 990 was announced and the Mirror, an alternative weekly, also shut down. But they are only the latest casualties.
Another smaller alternative weekly, the Hour, folded in May. The Gazette, the city’s last English-language daily, owned by Postmedia, recently directed another 20 newsroom employees to walk the plank within the next few months. And it’s been years since the city’s two glossy English monthlies, Montreal Magazine and MTL, were laid to rest.
Mitch Melnick, host of 990’s afternoon show, was quoted as saying: “When we started this station 11 years ago, a lot of us had great belief, unwavering belief, the city could support a sports station in both languages. We are part of the landscape (now) and, unfortunately, we’re going to disappear.”
[. . .]
David Novak, a retired newspaperman and film publicist, worries the recent losses are a sobering harbinger of tough times for Anglos.
While Montreal supports several French-language dailies — Le Devoir, La Presse, Le Journal, a free metro newspaper and the weekly alternative Voir — Novak says English print media is hurting. The city’s English population is declining, he says, and younger Allophones and Anglophones prefer screens and the Internet to newsprint.
“It’s a sign of the slow death of the traditional Anglophone community in Montreal,” he says. “My son is completely comfortable in French and even the Jewish community, which used to be Ashkenazi and speak English and Yiddish, is now increasingly Sephardic and speak French.”
Henry Aubin, a prizewinning longtime urban affairs columnist at The Gazette, says older readers “are not digitally oriented” and the loss of the two free weeklies and the cutbacks and staff shrinkage at the Gazette “are blows to the Anglo community’s ability to inform itself.”
“Staff cutbacks and a distant head office that devises uniform policies for its papers coast to coast have weakened The Gazette over the past decade or two,” he said in an email.
And,
The Suburban's take:
[C]ommunity weeklies such as the Suburban, the Westmount Examiner and the Independent are prospering, says David Price, editor of the weekly Westmount Independent. They have a simple game plan — distribute door to door, deliver local news and go after local retailers for ad revenue.
“We focus on a community as opposed to a demographic,” says Price.
The Suburban, which has for decades served suburbanites with local news tidbits and ads for area shops, has quickly revamped itself, adding a downtown section heavy on entertainment to attract former Mirror readers.
Suburban editor Beryl Wajsman says publishers cutting back in order to fulfill promises of quarterly increases in share value only put their newspapers on life support.
“The philosophy of growth is the philosophy of the cancer cell,” he says, pointing out that his circulation has expanded in the last year from 105,000 to 145,000 a week by trying to improve the paper, not reducing staff or page counts.
Thoughts?