rfmcdonald: (Default)
Science fiction author Ben Bova's Titan, the latest installment in his Grand Tour series, unfortunately shares in the weaknesses of too many of his other books. Are the characters cardboard creations awkwardly voicing several distinct political positions in the context of simplified and frankly unbelievable geopolitical and astronomical environments that might not even been fact-checked (Ontario Lacus appears to be the only lake-like body on Titan, for instance)? Yes, yes, yes. Oh, and isolated underpopulated space colonies can easily strike out on their own.
rfmcdonald: (Default)
I used to be a big fan of Ben Bova until I read his 1993 novel The Trikon Deception, co-authored with Bill Pogue. The plot's interesting enough, with a private corporation operating a high-security lab in Earth orbit tasked with preventing Earth's ecological collapse, but one lthrowaway line in a character's bio tripped me. She was born in Quebec City; she had experienced, Bova and Pogue went on to say, in a community that had experienced language strike.

Quebec City is 95% Francophone. If there's any Québec metropolis not torn by ethnic strife, Quebec City is it.

The failure of his fact-checking in this instance made me wonder just how much of his material was similarly wrong, in areas that I was unfamiliar with. Later, I came up with more reasons for distancing myself from Bova, like his wooden prose style and his identikit plots.
Page generated Apr. 24th, 2025 10:43 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios