- This 2013 Toronto Guardian article explains how the Korean community in Toronto can trace its origins to early 20th century missionaries from Canada.
- At Spacing, Daniel Panneton writes about the rise of fascism in Italian Toronto and the very different reactions to this ideology's rise.
- CBC Toronto reports on the popular new app Irish App-roved, aimed at helping new immigrants from Ireland get oriented in Toronto.
- Jacob Lorinc at the Toronto Star tells the story of Albino Carreira, a Portuguese-Canadian construction worker disabled by a construction incident in the 1990s who went on to whimsically decorate his Clinton Street home and his bug-covered van.
- The growing racialization of poverty in Toronto is a huge ongoing concern. The Toronto Star reports.
- Hornet Stories looks at the history of the queercore punk movement.
- Sarah Fonseca at them examines the subgenre of the lesbian pulp novel.
- CBC carries the argument of drag queen Halal Bae that, after RuPaul made drag mainstream, it's up to new artists like her to broaden the scope of the genre.
- I am strongly inclined to agree with Andrew Sullivan that the closeted corruption documented by Frédéric Martel in the Roman Catholic Church is morally repugnant. His New York blog has it.
- Kai Cheng Thom writes at Daily Xtra about the #MeToo movement in the context of queer communities, and the extra burdens it--and we--face.
- Toronto's Chinatown on Spadina Avenue is facing pressures from gentrification, including architectural ones, the Toronto Star observes.
- blogTO notes that the building housing shop Alternative Thinking is the only survivor of the old Honest Ed's-anchored Mirvish Village.
- Urban Toronto shares revised plans for 2452 Bloor Street West, in Bloor West Village near Jane.
- Black people in Toronto tend to live in "segregated" neighbourhoods, census and other data suggest, according to this article in the Toronto Star.
- Global News notes the demand of privacy commissioner Anne Cavoukian for the data being gathered by Waterfront Toronto in the Quayside project.
- The final cost of the Scarborough subway remains unknown, on account of the many design changes. The Toronto Star reports.
- Steve Benjamins reports on Toronto's Jimmy's Coffee.
- The old Fairland Grocery in Kensington Market on Augusta Avenue is being made over into a funhouse. (Tickets still available at print time.) NOW Toronto reports.
- The Malta Bake Shop in the Junction is trying to resist gentrification as best as it can. The National Post reports.
- The New York Times reports on a remarkably multilingual kindergarten in Thorncliffe Park.
[BLOG] Some Monday links
Jan. 29th, 2018 08:32 am- Crooked Timber links to John Quiggin's article in the Guardian about how formerly public companies should be renationalized.
- The Dragon's Tales notes that Lockheed has just signed a $US 150 million dollar contract to deliver a 60 kilowatt laser weapon to the US navy by 2020.
- Hornet Stories ranks the different performances at last night's Grammies, giving Kesha top placing.
- JSTOR Daily looks back to contemporary coverage of the 1918 flu epidemic. How did people react, how did they cope?
- Language Hat looks at a multilingual comic by Japan-born artist Ru Kawahata, Stuck in the Middle.
- Lawyers, Guns and Money suggests that, rather than hoping for Trump to perform to minimal expectations in the upcoming State of the Union address, it might be more profitable (and enjoyable?) to wait for the inevitable meltdown. What will it be?
- Marginal Revolution notes a proposal in Rotterdam for police to arrest people wearing expensive clothes and jewellery and, if they cannot explain where they got them, confiscate them. Of course this policy could not be misused.
- Towleroad notes that drag queens have quit Burkhart's, a prominent gay bar in Atlanta, in response to that bar's owner's racist and alt-right statements on Facebook.
- Paul Cassell at the Volokh Conspiracy argues Judge Rosemarie Aquilina was entirely correct in allowing all the victims of Nassar to speak at sentencing.
- Window on Eurasia notes that radical Islamists are increasingly using Russian to communicate, not the traditional languages of Russia's Muslim populations. Linguistic assimilation does not equal cultural assimilation.
[BLOG] Some Sunday links
Aug. 27th, 2017 01:33 pm- blogTO lists some interesting things to do and see in Toronto's American neighbour, Buffalo.
- The Broadside Blog's Caitlin Kelly strongly defends contemporary journalism as essential for understanding the world.
- Lawyers, Guns and Money rightly takes issue with the claim identity politics hinders the US left. Remember New Deal coalitions?
- Marginal Revolution notes just how expensive it is to run Harvard.
- Otto Pohl notes the upcoming 76th anniversary of the Soviet deportation of the Volga Germans.
- The Power and the Money's Noel Maurer reports on the remarkably fluent code-switching between English and French of some Washington D.C. subway riders.
- Strange Maps notes rival food and fabric maps of India and Pakistan.
- Tricia Wood at Torontoist argues that, for environmental and economic reasons, Ontario needs high-speed rail.
- Window on Eurasia suggests Tatarstan has done a poor job of defending its sovereignty from the Russian government.
Spacing's Jake Tobin Garrett has an interview with Jay Pitter looking at how parks can be critical bits of public space, especially in a multicultural community.
Jake Tobin Garrett: The vision of the organization you work for, the Inspirit Foundation, is to create a more inclusive and pluralist Canada where differences are valued and engaged. How do you see that vision relating to parks and public spaces?
Jay Pitter: In addition to acknowledging and addressing systemic inequities, we believe that encouraging an inclusive and pluralist Canada is predicated on encouraging people to engage each other across difference. The public realm plays a large role in that. The Inspirit Foundation supports many projects that leverage the public realm to bring people together to address issues that are paramount within their local context.
For instance, we funded an Edmonton-based project called iHuman. The project provides supports for Indigenous youth, many of whom are street-involved, to engage with the broader community in the public realm. Last year they hosted a block party and there were performances and workshops led by Indigenous youth who are street-involved engaging the wider community. What’s really exciting about this project is it really recast Indigenous youth who are experiencing homelessness from being a vulnerable to powerful. The project demonstrates their capacity not just their struggles; the public realm plays an integral role in amplifying this respectful approach to youth engagement and addressing systemic exclusion.
[BLOG] Some Tuesday links
Nov. 22nd, 2016 10:59 am- blogTO shares some photos of Toronto in colour from the 1950s.
- Centauri Dreams talks about SETI in the light of the Anthropocene era.
- Dangerous Minds notes that there is now a hipster nativity scene available for purchase.
- The Dragon's Gaze links to a paper suggesting that tidal heating could explain the difference between super-Earths and mini-Neptunes.
- Joe. My. God. notes that protecting Trump in New York City costs that municipality a million dollars a day, and notes a parade of Spanish fascists in support of Trump.
- Lawyers, Guns and Money notes that politics is identity politics.
- The LRB Blog notes the end of Sarkozy's campaign and revisits Goldwater.
- The Russian Demographics Blog reports on the latest about the population of Ukraine.
- Towleroad notes the hateful mail received by an out mayor in Massachusetts.
- The Volokh Conspiracy looks at Trump's apparently anti-constitutional entanglement of business and politics.
- Window on Eurasia reports on how Russia's promotion of the Russian language in neighbouring countries is backfiring, and looks at the hard nationalist line of Patriarch Kirill against Ukrainian autocephaly and multiculturalism in Russia.
This news item from Global News highlights how the US-Canadian border, a thin line even on the map, is in reality wholly imaginary. Counting on the border alone as a defense is a poor idea.
Toronto police have launched an investigation after residents in the city’s east-end found “ultra right wing” posters that urged white people “tired of political correctness” and “questioning when immigration will stop” to join an online movement they suspect arose out of Donald Trump’s election win.
The signs have a bold headline that reads “Hey, WHITE PERSON” and ask, “wondering why only white countries have to become ‘multicultural’?” and “figuring out that diversity only means less white people’?”
They also called for those with similar thinking to join the “alt-right” political movement on several conservative Canadian and American websites.
“I found the posters very disturbing, residents in my ward sent it this morning. I think the sentiments expressed in the poster are totally unacceptable in this city and it’s very worrisome,” Coun. Janet Davis told Global News Monday, after the signs turned up in Ward 31 Beaches-East York.
“I’m quite worried that the Donald Trump election has legitimized this kind of ultra right wing viewpoint and encouraged these kinds of expressions of hate.”
Spacing Toronto's Fatima Syed looks at how a spat involving online racism and Mississauga's mayor illustrates failings in that city's multiculturalism/
Earlier this month, Mississauga mayor Bonnie Crombie was lauded for standing up against racism for the second time in a year. On Sunday Oct. 9, she filed a hate hate-crime complaint with Peel police after a local website published an article claiming she “is converting Mississauga into a dangerous Islamic war zone” so “they can kill her son just for being gay.”
The article comes a year after Mississauga council approved the zoning application for the Meadowvale Islamic Centre. During one council committee meeting, Crombie shamed Kevin Johnston, owner of the website that published the article, for distributing flyers denigrating the Muslim community and strongly petitioning against the construction of a mosque.
“Racism and flat-out lies have no place in Mississauga,” Crombie told the Toronto Star, in a statement that was widely celebrated as strong leadership.
Denouncing racism, however, is a reaction that occurs only after it has reared its ugly head. Crombie’s moves, both times, outwardly demonstrate her intention to tackle racism head-on. But they are little more than symbolic gestures, underscoring Mississauga’s preferred image of itself as a seemingly open and welcoming multicultural city. The fact is that her denunciations don’t address the reality that the Mississauga council continues to both govern and plan in a way that marginalizes its new immigrant communities, explicitly creating political spaces for racism to exist.
Like most multicultural cities, Mississauga embodies a great display of urban diversity, with 47% of residents reporting a mother language other than English. For many, it is an advertisement for global urbanism, where ethno-cultural pockets exist side by side, each with their own sounds, smells and signs.
But the city’s social diversity isn’t working as well as it may outward appear.
[BLOG] Some Monday links
Oct. 17th, 2016 07:41 am- The Dragon's Gaze links to a paper noting how Tau Ceti's debris disk is not like our solar system's.
- Language Hat talks about writers who want anonymity.
- Joe. My. God. notes the return of homophobic protesters in France.
- The Map Room Blog shares hazard maps of various Yukon communities.
- Marginal Revolution notes that India's biometric smartcards work, and notes diversity does not reduce economic growth.
- Peter Rukavina shares some late 1990s photos of cows taken with an early digital camera.
- The Volokh Conspiracy notes the recent controversy over Ruth Bader Ginsburg.
- Window on Eurasia argues Russia might invade Ukraine more openly before January but also suggests that Russia is quite brittle.
CBC reports on one southwest Ontario mayor determined to oppose monarchy to multiculturalism. The irony of the photo that CBC used to illustrate the monarchs--William and Kate participating in a First Nations drum ceremony--is likely beyond him.
As the royal tour makes its way through Canada, one southwest Ontario mayor is calling on Canada to scrap its current multicultural policies and focus on ties to the monarchy.
[. . .]
Paterson stood by his Facebook comments Monday, telling CBC he welcomes new Canadians from around the world. But he expects them to conform to Canadian culture.
"If you're going to come to Canada and swear allegiance to Canada, which includes an allegiance to the monarchy, then be Canadian, that's all I'm saying," Paterson said. "Don't force us to change our ways. Come to Canada and be Canadian."
Paterson said he's not criticizing immigrants, but federal programs promoting multiculturalism. To Paterson, those come at the expense of traditions like the British monarchy.
On a bright warm day like today, why not talk about sports?

Joyita Sengupta's Torontoist post "Raptors Fans Were Always The Other" writes about the extent to which the Toronto Raptors, Toronto's NBA basketball team and the only such team in Canada, is a badge of pride for new Canadians. For people of recent immigrant background, this is the sport they connect with.

Joyita Sengupta's Torontoist post "Raptors Fans Were Always The Other" writes about the extent to which the Toronto Raptors, Toronto's NBA basketball team and the only such team in Canada, is a badge of pride for new Canadians. For people of recent immigrant background, this is the sport they connect with.
I grew up in a basketball neighbourhood. It was the stretch of Dixon Road between Islington and Kipling avenues, predominantly made up of Somali or South Asian immigrants. Despite our 416 area code, you would be hard pressed to see a Leafs jersey anywhere on my block. I can’t say I’ve met anyone from Dixon that was on a Little League team, either. However, without fail, as soon as school let out kids would run to the back of the local elementary school to shoot around whenever it was warm enough to. The older boys dominated the court, sandwiched between the six white, brick high rises, donated to the neighbourhood by iconic former Toronto Raptor Vince Carter in 2003. Despite never playing ball (or any sports, for that matter), I still get a tinge of hometown and neighbourhood pride when I walk by that court and see the VC logo on the now well-worn backboards.
At the core of being a Raptors fan is this sense you were always the “other” in Canada and Leafs-obsessed Toronto, long before the team was left out of CBS Sports’s poll, sparking #WeTheOther. Even with success of the “We The North” branding, the franchise hasn’t always received a lot of support outside of Southern Ontario. But as the Raptors wade deeper into the post-season than ever before, their fans are being put under the microscope.
Out of the words that have been used to describe Raptors fan, “young” and “diverse” are most used. An Indiana Pacers fan from south of the border was perplexed by all the “Canadian Indian Muslims” that travel town to town to support the team. They’ve also been described as some of the most dedicated, energetic fans in the league. “Not normal,” one Indiana columnist called them. These distinctions bring Raptors fans together.
[BLOG] Some Thursday links
Dec. 3rd, 2015 01:34 pm- The Dragon's Gaze links to a paper considering rates of water loss in a moist greenhouse world's atmosphere.
- The Dragon's Tales notes that leftists in Catalonia blocked separatists from forming the government.
- Far Outliers notes Persian cultural influence in the South Caucasus, among Christian and Muslim cultures alike.
- Joe. My. God. notes that the Catholic cardinal of the Dominican Republic insulted the gay American ambassador in a manner combining homophobia with misogyny.
- Language Log notes the growing multilingualism of Hong Kong, beyond Chinese languages.
- Lawyers, Guns and Money responds to a feminist criticism of Jessica Jones, and notes it is entirely possible to respond to a feminist criticism without sending death or rape threats.
- Towleroad notes the publication, by the Russian edition of Maxim, of a list of gay respected by the magazine.
- Transit Toronto notes that you only need proof of payment to board streetcars by any door.
- Window on Eurasia notes a move in Russia to undermine that country's ethnofederalism, to the demerit of minority peoples like the Tatars.
- Yorkshire Ranter Alex Harrowell notes how the old habit of the Enlightenment to organize museums by curiosities does not work if you use artifacts from indigenous peoples in the mix.
The Toronto Star's Peter Edwards reports on patterns in Google searches in Toronto. I would suggest that another explanation might be that users of Chinese languages use search engines other than Google, Baidu for instance.
Toronto has a large Chinese community, but there’s not much Chinese-language Googling out of the GTA. But Toronto has a far smaller Spanish-language community, and Spanish is the most-used language for Googling from here, after the official languages of English and French.
Those are a few of the findings of a just-released study by the Google News Lab.
The study breaks down the estimated more than 3 billion searches a day globally by language and city for Berlin, Delhi, London, Madrid, New York, Paris, Sao Paulo, Shanghai and Toronto.
“It’s interesting,” McMaster University sociology professor Vic Satzewich said in an interview.
Satzewich, who has studied patterns of immigration, suggested ebbs and flows in immigration and tourism help explain the Googling patterns.
He suggested that the low number of Chinese-language Googlers from the GTA might be reflected in part by an effort by the government to attract immigrants who are strong in Canada’s two official languages.
The high Spanish-language Googling from the GTA could reflect an increase in temporary workers from Mexico and Guatamala over the past decade.
CBC News notes the decline of some prominent non-English television programs in Canada. Is this a marker of the decline of television generally, and the shift to online sources?
Rogers Media has cancelled multicultural news programs in Ontario and B.C. and will replace them with new current affairs programming targeting the same audience.
On Thursday, Rogers Media said in a release that it will air three new half-hour current affairs programs that will air in multiple languages in the 8:30 to 10 p.m. timeslot. The new shows will be hosted by "veteran OMNI Television on-air personalities," Rogers said.
Those shows will replace 30-minute newscasts that used to air weeknights on OMNI's local channels. Unifor, one of the largest media unions in the country, said Rogers is also cancelling V-Mix and Bollywood Boulevard, two English-language programs for South Asian audiences.
[DM] "Taiwan's growing multiculturalism"
Feb. 18th, 2015 11:56 pmI've a Demography Matters post linking to Sinclaire Prowse's article in The Diplomat noting the continuing evolution of Taiwan, via international migration, into a more multicultural society.
Writing for the Huffington Post, Susan Khazaeli and Nicole Waintraub describe the latest small scandal of the Canadian federal government.
A Conservative Toronto MP, Chungsen Leung, recently attended an event organized by the Association of North American Ethnic Journalists and Writers. During the meet-and-greet, Mr. Leung was asked about the increasing difficulties faced by Iranians attempting to obtain a Canadian Visa. Emotions apparently ran high. At one point, in a heated exchange, Mr. Leung asked a member of the audience, "If you like Iran so much then why do you come to Canada?"
He then demanded to know: "Why are you here?" Some audience members were so offended by his comments and his dismissive attitude -- which one attendee characterized as "arrogant" -- that they decided to leave the event.
Mr. Leung is also the Parliamentary Secretary for Multiculturalism. It kind of sounds like a bad joke, doesn't it?
According to a CTV report, Mr. Leung's office claims that the exchange was a "miscommunication." His email apology expressed regret for the misunderstanding. Perhaps Mr. Leung's comments were off-the-cuff, but they were, by no means, innocuous.
Even if unintentional, Mr. Leung's comments were discriminatory and hostile. The subtext of the messaging is: "Why don't you go back where you came from?" They betray an underlying attitude that many non-white Canadians encounter when expressing views critical of government policy. This attitude becomes even more pronounced when that non-white Canadian comes from a country that, like Iran, is on the outs with Canada.
[BLOG] Some Monday links
Apr. 7th, 2014 12:45 pm- Bad Astronomy's Phil Plait evaluates a video of a skydiver almost hit by a meteroroid and finds it plausible.
- The Dragon's Gaze links to a paper suggesting that we don't know which processes lead to stars and which to brown dwarfs.
- Language Log's Mark Liberman notes interesting gendered pronoun usage in a new science fiction novel.
- Lawyers, Guns and Money is not sympathetic towards Brandon Eich and argues that multicultural accomodation isn't inherently irrational.
- Marginal Revolution seems to have grudging respect for Michael Lewis' new book Flash Boys.
- Towleroad notes the recent statement of Justin Welby, the Archbishop of Canterbury and head of the Church of England, that embracing same-sex marriage could inadvertently lead to the persecution and murder of Christians around in the world, particularly in Africa. (One finds one's allies where one can.
- At Window on Eurasia, note is made of various arguments: one argues that Russian national identity is synthetic and assimilatory; another argues that, given Ukrainian public opinion, Russia's only prospects for further expansion lie in force; still another takes note of Eurasianist threats against Azerbaijan.
There's been a minor political scandal precipitated by the impolitic statements of Jason Kenney, the Canadian federal Minister of Citizenship, Immigration and Multiculturalism, on Canadian Gaelic, the branch of Scots Gaelic that was transplanted across the Atlantic Ocean to Atlantic Canada--particularly Nova Scotia's Cape Breton Island, but also to the remainder of that province as well as my own Prince Edward Island.
For a greater taste of popular sentiment, see the multiple angry comments at the website of the Halifax Chronicle-Herald.
An opinion piece published in that same paper written by one Jerry White argues that Gaelic can still be saved.
The thing is, Canadian Gaelic is in a far, far worse position than the people who compare it to Romansh or Yiddish, never mind French, seem to realize. Canadian French is spoken by a solid bloc of seven million people, about half of whom can only speak Canadian French, who live concentrated in a single province where Francophones form the majority population, one branch of a worldwide Francophone community where regular speakers number in excess of a hundred million people. Yiddish is the traditional language of the Ashkenazic Jews, at its pre-Holocaust peak spoken by millions of people around the world and widely used in all fields of public and private life, still spoken regularly despite everything by substantial numbers? Romansh? That language, as I noted in 2009, is spoken by tens of thousands of people but is arguably doomed by, among other things, the division of a small language community into smaller factions as each tries to promote its own dialect.
Canadian Gaelic, at last count, is nearly moribund, with just over two thousand people in all of Canada speaking it as their mother tongue as of the 2011 census. Even if they all lived in Nova Scotia, that would still amount to a third of a percent of that province's population.
Canadian Gaelic shouldn't be compared with Punjabi or Mandarin, I agree: those two languages are much more widely spoken within Canada and have more promising futures. If the current support lent to Gaelic by Nova Scotia's government had been given a century ago, perhaps the language would have a brighter future. As things stand, I actually tend to agree with Kenney on the grounds that spending federal funds promoting a moribund language that no one cared much for until very recently is a waste of federal funds.
Gaelic speaking Nova Scotians are not happy with federal minister Jason Kenney.
Kenney has weighed in on the merits of the language and the government's role in preserving it. Kenney said federal government money should not be used to promote languages that are fighting for survival.
"I think we should focus on the common languages that unite us in our diversity, English and French," said Kenney. "I encourage communities to maintain their heritage languages, be they Gaelic or Punjabi or Mandarin, but that they do so with their own funds."
In the Cape Breton community of Mabou, those words are not going over well. In Mabou, you'll find street and road signs that show you the Gaelic language is alive and well.
Former Nova Scotia Premier and now CEO of the Gaelic College, Rodney MacDonald, said the Gaelic language is the cultural fabric of the Celtic community.
"I think the minister should apologize to the Gaelic community of Nova Scotia. He should apologize for the remarks. They were inappropriate. Like they say in politics, it's never too late to do the right thing."
For the last six years, the Nova Scotia government has had an Office of Gaelic Affairs. This year's budget is a little more than $500,000.
At the local grocery store in the heart of the community, people were saying the Gaelic language is important.
"It's a cultural thing and it's as important as Mi'kmaq and French is to the culture of the country," said Janice Langille. "It's all part and parcel of our heritage and should be preserved."
"Well there's a lot of things in French is that a waste of money," said Maureen Hart.
For a greater taste of popular sentiment, see the multiple angry comments at the website of the Halifax Chronicle-Herald.
An opinion piece published in that same paper written by one Jerry White argues that Gaelic can still be saved.
Nova Scotia Gaelic is facing its “Yiddish moment.” Yiddish was, for generations, the language of the shtetl, the small Jewish communities of central and eastern Europe whose culture was dealt its final blow by the Holocaust, just as Gaelic was once the language of the Highlands and was dealt its near-death blow by the Highland Clearances.
Both Yiddish and Gaelic made it over to the New World and, for a while, did fairly well; Yiddish was once very strong indeed in New York (where the Yiddish edition of the newspaper The Forward is still published) and Montreal, just as Gaelic was once an inescapable part of the life of Cape Breton. And both languages have declined very sharply.
Both have some fluent speakers left, but with Yiddish as with Gaelic, most are elderly. Younger people who consider either language part of their identity rarely (not never, but rarely) know enough to hold down a conversation. It’s more typical for them to know snatches: songs, little sayings, a few words and phrases. Nobody who spends any time getting to know either Gaelic or Yiddish can avoid seeing that reality.
It does not have to be that way. Gaelic speakers have rights, and they could start to assert those rights more forcefully. Nova Scotia’s Office of Gaelic Affairs offers a model of how that could be done. Anyone who has visited their website knows that every-thing they do is available in Gaelic. Everyone who has been to an event where they are present has seen their indefatigable chief Lewis MacKinnon speaking mellifluous Gaelic; whenever he says anything in public, he says it in Gaelic first, and then repeats it in English. The office is fully capable of doing the everyday and sometimes tedious work of government in Gaelic.
Rodney MacDonald is working to move St. Ann’s Colaisde na Gàidhlig, formerly known as the Gaelic College, in the same direction. Institutions like these are pointing those of us who care about Gaelic’s future as a living language away from the realm of the folkloric and sentimental, and towards the reality of the world we live in.
They are pointing us towards Romansh. Romansh is, along with German, French and Italian, one of Switzerland’s four “national languages.” But unlike the other three, it’s not an “official language.” The Swiss government doesn’t use it more than it has to, and you don’t encounter it much outside of small mountain communities, where it has always had to struggle against German for survival. But Romansh speakers have made a lot of progress over the last years.
Advocates of Nova Scotia Gaelic have worked hard to get the language in more schools, and that’s a struggle in Romansh communities as well. Nova Scotians who drive towards Cape Breton start to notice bilingual signage as the approach the causeway, and signage is an area where Romansh communities have actually done quite well. You can get your phone bill in Romansh, if you ask for it.
The thing is, Canadian Gaelic is in a far, far worse position than the people who compare it to Romansh or Yiddish, never mind French, seem to realize. Canadian French is spoken by a solid bloc of seven million people, about half of whom can only speak Canadian French, who live concentrated in a single province where Francophones form the majority population, one branch of a worldwide Francophone community where regular speakers number in excess of a hundred million people. Yiddish is the traditional language of the Ashkenazic Jews, at its pre-Holocaust peak spoken by millions of people around the world and widely used in all fields of public and private life, still spoken regularly despite everything by substantial numbers? Romansh? That language, as I noted in 2009, is spoken by tens of thousands of people but is arguably doomed by, among other things, the division of a small language community into smaller factions as each tries to promote its own dialect.
Canadian Gaelic, at last count, is nearly moribund, with just over two thousand people in all of Canada speaking it as their mother tongue as of the 2011 census. Even if they all lived in Nova Scotia, that would still amount to a third of a percent of that province's population.
Canadian Gaelic shouldn't be compared with Punjabi or Mandarin, I agree: those two languages are much more widely spoken within Canada and have more promising futures. If the current support lent to Gaelic by Nova Scotia's government had been given a century ago, perhaps the language would have a brighter future. As things stand, I actually tend to agree with Kenney on the grounds that spending federal funds promoting a moribund language that no one cared much for until very recently is a waste of federal funds.