- Reddit's unresolvedmysteries highlights a historical conundrum: Who were these hundreds of people from all over Asia who died in a remote district of the Indian Himalayas centuries ago?
- Smithsonian Magazine notes why 18th century Europeans prized even wildly inaccurate maps and images of colonial cities in the Americas.
- J.M. Opal's argument at The Conversation that the United States, dominated by a rigid oligarchy, is as unreformable as 18th century Britain is depressing.
- The suggestion of Dan Malleck at The Conversation, looking back at the Ontario pre-Prohibition history of unregulated alcohol sales, that the Ford deregulation of marijuana sales might be short-sighted, seems plausible.
- George Dvorsky at Gizmodo shares the latest evidence that pre-contact Easter Island did not undergo a great violent collapse, with no signs of a major conflict.
- The Counterfactual History Review takes/u> a look at the plausibility of Wakanda, as a society, and finds it holds up. (There's something to be said about having the problems of one's own society being indigenous, not imposed by colonizers.)
- This article takes a look at the interest of Lesotho, a mountainous kingdom of southern Africa that was never quite fully colonized, on the idea of Wakanda.
- What is the relationship of Wakanda to Africa and the wider black diaspora? This article makes an argument. (Spoilers.)
- Queer representation in Wakanda is a real thing. All the more frustrating, then, if it is not quite realized.
- The Toronto Public Library's The Buzz points readers to more comics exploring Black Panther and Wakanda.
- Vulture takes a look at Christopher Priest, the writer who helped make Black Panther the character he is today more than a decade ago but then disappeared.
Today particularly, I've been posting a lot of links about First Nations, their identities and the political movements and their cultural revivals. This year does seem to be a big year for indigenous movement, building on previous protests like last year's Idle No More movement.
What do you see coming of all this?
Discuss.
What do you see coming of all this?
Discuss.
[BLOG] Some Thursday links
Sep. 15th, 2016 10:04 am- blogTO notes how expensive Toronto's rental market is.
- Centauri Dreams looks at the TRAPPIST-1 exoplanet system.
- Crooked Timber engages with the complexities of racism.
- The Crux shares some oral history about the detection of the first gravitational wave.
- The Dragon's Gaze reports about the difficulties involved with detecting exoplanets around red dwarfs and describes the discovery of a super-Earth orbiting an orange dwarf in the Pleiades.
- Joe. My. God. notes that New York City ended free web browsing at browsing stations because people kept looking up porn.
- Language Log notes that a partially shared script does not make Chinese readable by speakers of Japanese, and vice versa.
- Marginal Revolution cautions against the idea that Brexit is over.
- The Power and the Money's Noel Maurer talks about the usefulness of counterfactuals, especially good counterfactuals.
- Torontoist argues that the TTC needs more cats. Why not?
- The Volokh Conspiracy links to a comparative global study of settlements in occupied territories.
- Window on Eurasia reports that Google has displaced television as a primary source of news for Russians.
[LINK] "Facebook and the New Colonialism"
Feb. 12th, 2016 04:37 pmThe Atlantic's Adrienne Lafrance examines how Facebook stumbled into a needless confrontation over colonialism in India.
Mark Zuckerberg hasn’t had the best week.
First, Facebook’s Free Basics platform was effectively banned in India. Then, a high-profile member of Facebook’s board of directors, the venture capitalist Marc Andreessen, sounded off about the decision to his nearly half-a-million Twitter followers with a stunning comment.
“Anti-colonialism has been economically catastrophic for the Indian people for decades,” Andreessen wrote. “Why stop now?”
After that, the Internet went nuts.
Andreessen deleted his tweet, apologized, and underscored that he is “100 percent opposed to colonialism” and “100 percent in favor of independence and freedom.” Zuckerberg, Facebook’s CEO, followed up with his own Facebook post to say Andreessen’s comment was “deeply upsetting” to him, and not representative of the way he thinks “at all.”
The kerfuffle elicited a torrent of criticism for Andreessen, but the connection he made—between Facebook’s global expansion and colonialism—is nothing new. Which probably helps explain why Zuckerberg felt the need to step in, and which brings us back to Free Basics. The platform, billed by Facebook as a way to help people connect to the Internet for the first time, offers a stripped-down version of the mobile web that people can use without it counting toward their data-usage limit.
Al Jazeera reports on the noteworthy impending recognition by Germany of the campaign waged againdt the Herero of then-German Southwest Africa as genocide.
German authorities are set to officially recognize as "genocide" the colonial-era crackdown in Namibia by German troops more than a century ago in which over 65,000 ethnic Hereros were killed.
Talks with Namibia on a joint declaration about the events of the early 20th century are ongoing, and it isn't clear when they will be concluded, German Foreign Ministry spokesman Martin Schaefer said Friday.
The basis for the German government's approach is a parliamentary motion signed three years ago by Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier, stating that "the war of destruction in Namibia from 1904 to 1908 was a war crime and genocide," Schaefer said. Steinmeier was an opposition leader at the time, and the motion didn't pass.
German Gen. Lothar von Trotha — who was sent to what was then South West Africa to put down an uprising by the Hereros against their German rulers in 1904 — instructed his troops to wipe out the entire tribe in what is widely seen as the 20th century’s first genocide, historians say.
On Oct. 2, 1904, Trotha issued a proclamation: “Within the German boundaries, every Herero, whether found armed or unarmed, with or without cattle will be shot. I shall not accept more women and children. … I shall order shots to be fired at them.”
Rounded up in prison camps, captured Hereros and as well as members of the Nama tribe died from malnutrition and severe weather. Dozens were beheaded after their deaths and their skulls sent to German researchers in Berlin for "scientific" experiments.
In an essay at The Atlantic that demonstrates his typical brilliance, "What This Cruel War Was Over", Ta-Nehisi Coates goes to great lengths to demonstrate that the Confederacy--and, by extension, its flag--were all about slavery and white racism.
I was pleased to see this reference:
The island country of Genosha in the Marvel universe is a state off the east African coast notorious for its practice of mutant slavery.
If only I could exercise my wit and intelligence in as thorough and topical a manner as Coates! Read the essay: it's superb.
This afternoon, in announcing her support for removing the Confederate flag from the capitol grounds, South Carolina Governor Nikki Haley asserted that killer Dylann Roof had “a sick and twisted view of the flag” which did not reflect “the people in our state who respect and in many ways revere it.” If the governor meant that very few of the flag’s supporters believe in mass murder, she is surely right. But on the question of whose view of the Confederate Flag is more twisted, she is almost certainly wrong.
Roof’s belief that black life had no purpose beyond subjugation is “sick and twisted” in the exact same manner as the beliefs of those who created the Confederate flag were “sick and twisted.” The Confederate flag is directly tied to the Confederate cause, and the Confederate cause was white supremacy. This claim is not the result of revisionism. It does not require reading between the lines. It is the plain meaning of the words of those who bore the Confederate flag across history. These words must never be forgotten. Over the next few months the word “heritage” will be repeatedly invoked. It would be derelict to not examine the exact contents of that heritage.
This examination should begin in South Carolina, the site of our present and past catastrophe. South Carolina was the first state to secede, two months after the election of Abraham Lincoln. It was in South Carolina that the Civil War began, when the Confederacy fired on Fort Sumter. The state’s casus belli was neither vague nor hard to comprehend:...A geographical line has been drawn across the Union, and all the States north of that line have united in the election of a man to the high office of President of the United States, whose opinions and purposes are hostile to slavery. He is to be entrusted with the administration of the common Government, because he has declared that that “Government cannot endure permanently half slave, half free,” and that the public mind must rest in the belief that slavery is in the course of ultimate extinction. This sectional combination for the submersion of the Constitution, has been aided in some of the States by elevating to citizenship, persons who, by the supreme law of the land, are incapable of becoming citizens; and their votes have been used to inaugurate a new policy, hostile to the South, and destructive of its beliefs and safety.
In citing slavery, South Carolina was less an outlier than a leader, setting the tone for other states[.]
I was pleased to see this reference:
Thus in 1861, when the Civil War began, the Union did not face a peaceful Southern society wanting to be left alone. It faced an an aggressive power, a Genosha, an entire society based on the bondage of a third of its residents, with dreams of expanding its fields of the bondage further South. It faced the dream of a vast American empire of slavery.
The island country of Genosha in the Marvel universe is a state off the east African coast notorious for its practice of mutant slavery.
If only I could exercise my wit and intelligence in as thorough and topical a manner as Coates! Read the essay: it's superb.

This May 2013 photo was taken as I was walking with my father down the former course of Garrison Creek, along Bathurst Street near Fort York. On the side of a stairway leading from the street towards the fort, builders had erected a wall with a potted history of the Toronto area, the only entry relating to native peoples being a notation that First Nations settled the area circa 9000 BC. Below that entry, someone had scrawled some graffiti: "But they weren't doing much, so we killed them all ... ?"
First Nations erasure is a major problem in Canadian history. In this particular case, the graffiti artist missed a singular point about Toronto's pre-European history, that there were no mass killings of indingenous peoples by Europeans, that the main mass killings were conducted by other indigenous peoples. The mid-17th century Beaver Wars fought for control of the North American fur trade ended up seeing the dispersion of the native groups indigenous to south-central Ontario, notably the Huron. C.M.W. Marcel's 2006 Counterweights essay goes into interesting detail about the ephemeral Iroquois colonization of the northern shores of Lake Ontario. This settlement included two villages in modern Toronto's boundaries, Teiaiagon on the eastern shore of the Humber River in west-end Toronto and Ganatsekwyagon in east-end Toronto on the Rouge River. That first village later hosted the Mississaugas, an Algonquian-speaking Ojibwa group that has since been displaced from the area. (Wayne Roberts' 2013 NOW Toronto essay is recommended.)
History is interesting.
[BLOG] Some Tuesday links
May. 21st, 2013 12:02 pm- Bag News Notes isn't impressed by the scandal aroused by Arne Svenson's photos of New York City condo dwellers taken through their windows--they are open, aren't they?
- Beyond the Beyond links to an interview with Chinese science fiction writer Fei Dao about that genre in China.
- Burgh Diaspora's Jim Russell writes about the problems of rural America in keeping talent.
- The Dragon's Tales and Jonathan Crowe both link to the new cartographic map of Saturn's moon Titan.
- Far Outliers' quotes from Chinua Achebe's latest book, this quote a recounting of the geographic and social origins of nationalism in Nigeria.
- Geocurrents notes the patterns and causes of Stalin's deportation of ethnic minorities from frontier zones, from Finland through to Siberia.
- Terrible news from Normblog's Norman Geras, who is currently being hospitalized for prostate cancer.
- Torontoist reports on the multimedia efforts of a Torontonian looking for a cat lost at College and Dovercourt.
- The Way the Future Blogs' Frederik Pohl writes about Brooklyn's joys.
- Window on Eurasia notes that Kyrgyzstan is the latest former Soviet state to downgrade the status of the Russian language.
In August of 2008, I took two photos of the statue of South American liberator Simón Bolivar, located in the northwest corner of Trinity Bellwoods Park. just south of Dundas Street West. here and here. On Sunday, I revisited the site and took another photo.

The various plaques reveal that this statue was a gift from the Municipality of Caracas to the City of Toronto in 1983 on behalf of the countries he liberated (Venezuela, Colombia, Panama, Ecuador, Peru, Bolivia) as well as, as John Warkentin notes in his book Creating Memory on public statuary in Toronto, Chile. This Peruvian community website hints at the statue playing an important symbolic role for the Latin American communities of Toronto, concentrated in (among other places) this neighbourhood, while more recently Venezuela’s rise as a radical political force named after Bolivar has helped make it noteworthy for left-wing radicals--a vigil was held by the statue after the death of Hugo Chavez

The various plaques reveal that this statue was a gift from the Municipality of Caracas to the City of Toronto in 1983 on behalf of the countries he liberated (Venezuela, Colombia, Panama, Ecuador, Peru, Bolivia) as well as, as John Warkentin notes in his book Creating Memory on public statuary in Toronto, Chile. This Peruvian community website hints at the statue playing an important symbolic role for the Latin American communities of Toronto, concentrated in (among other places) this neighbourhood, while more recently Venezuela’s rise as a radical political force named after Bolivar has helped make it noteworthy for left-wing radicals--a vigil was held by the statue after the death of Hugo Chavez
[BLOG] Some Wednesday links
Apr. 3rd, 2013 12:26 pm- Bag News Notes takes a look at the political iconography surrounding Chinese first lady, and patriotic singer, Peng Liuang.
- BCer in Toronto Jeff Jedras doesn't like suggestion like the one made by Liberal leadership candidate Joyce Murray that, in order to bring down Harper, the NDP and Liberals should consider not running candidates in ridings where one party or another might break through against Conservatives. He favours a distinctly Liberal vision (which is?).
- Beyond the Beyond's Bruce Sterling notes the recent finding that up to a third of American counties have declining populations.
- Daniel Drezner suggests that Europeans were never as strongly wedding to multilateralism as many, including Europeans, alleged.
- Eastern Approaches notes the failure of European Union-mediated talks between Kosova and Serbia, a consequence of Serbian resentment at the loss of Kosova.
- Geocurrents' Martin Lewis maps global cell phone usage, which maps poorly with GDP per capita or wealth. Eastern European countries often have higher rates of cell phone ownership per person than western Europeans, for instance.
- Joe. My. God notes that the Irish Roman Catholic Church has threatened to respond to a legalization of same-sex marriage in that country by no longer solemnizing marriages, forcing couples to engage in a separate state ceremony. (This could backfire.)
- Personal Reflections' Jim Belshaw argues that his home region of New England, in coastal eastern Australia, is an important political bellweather for his country.
- At the Planetary Science Blog, Marc Rayman writes about how his team is preparing for the Dawn probe's upcoming encounter with Ceres in two years.
- Torontoist notes the happy news that Toronto sex shop Come As You Are has avoided closing down thanks to a successful online promotional campaign.
- Window on Eurasia's Paul Goble notes various sources claiming that the 900 thousand ethnic Russians of Uzbekistan are increasingly unhappy living in a country where the Russian language is dropping out of general usage, the Russian colonial past in Uzbekistan is being criticized, and the only thing keeping many from leaving for Russia is a lack of means.
[BLOG] Some Monday links
Feb. 25th, 2013 12:37 pm- At Geocurrents, Asya Pereltsvaig takes on the provocative, if apparently ill-founded, thesis that Ashkenazic Jews trace their ancestry to the medieval Khazars of the Russian steppe by taking a look at the structure of the Yiddish language.
- Language Hat claims that, with the advent of electronic communications which make them difficult to insert into text, diacritical marks are endangered in the Polish language. A campaign has been launched.
- At Lawyers, Guns and Money, Erik Loomis links to an essay by feminist and historian Ruth Rosen wherein she states--basically--that early feminists didn't think about campaigning against violence against women in the 1970s because violence against women was taken for granted as inevitable.
- British journalist Mark Simpson unearths a vintage article about Napster and the Internet and free culture from 2001 that's still relevant today.
- Marginal Revolution's Tyler Cowen links approvingly to a book, Cuisine, Colonialism and Cold War: Food in Twentieth Century Korea by Katarzyna J. Cwiertka, that examines "Korean-Japanese relations, the early history of Korean industrialization, and the rise of industrial food, as well as the evolution of Korean food in recent times". It does look interesting.
- Naked Anthropologist Laura Agustín takes a look at the ways in which the sex industry of New York City's Times Square was an integral part of the neighbourhood, in photos and posters.
- Torontoist notes that City Council has just declared Toronto a sanctuary city, guaranteeing undocumented residents access to municipal services. More on this later.
- Eugene Volokh in a couple of posts (1, 2) starts speculating whether or not indigenous peoples in the New World would have seen European migrants as illegal immigrants and starts to head in problematic directions. Again, more later.
- John Scalzi at Whatever shares his love of libraries.
- Window on Eurasia's Paul Goble notes, via various sources, that Chechen refugees in the European Union are facing forced returns to their ever-problematic homeland.
[BLOG] Some Wednesday links
Jan. 23rd, 2013 11:49 am- Dan Hirschman, Budding Sociologist, takes issue with Michael Shermer's claim that the left is as anti-science as the right.
- Daniel Drezner strongly disagrees with the contention of Roger Cohen that American diplomacy is impossible. It's simply more complicated than before, with more and more transparent actors.
- Far Outliers compares policies towards indigenous languages in the early Spanish and English empires, noting that in Spanish territories native languages like Nahuatl and Quechua were promoted for evangelism's sake while in New England English was pushed on the indigenous populations.
- At A Fistful of Euros, Alex Harrowell notes the ongoing capital shortage in central Europe and has a news roundup from the region.
- GNXP's Razib Khan reviews two books on the spread of Christianity in the Roman Empire, noting that it was as much achieved through fiat on the part of the elites as it was through mass conversions.
- Lawyers, Guns and Money's Scott Lemieux makes the point that arguably worse than Lance Armstrong's cheating was the fact that he treated people who pointed out his cheating viciously.
- Strange Maps introduces its readers to the five types of territorial morphology of states.
- Window on Eurasia's Paul Goble has three posts about policing the fringes of the Russian ethnos, starting with the desire of some inhabitants of the Russian-populated province of Stavropol in the largely non-Russian North Caucasus Federal District to gain status as a Russian republic, to charges of treason levied against a Pomor activist fron a distinctive Russian subgrouping on the White Sea to controversy surrounding Cossack patrols.
[BLOG] Some Friday links
Jan. 18th, 2013 01:08 pm- Centauri Dreams' Paul Gilster writes about long-lived artifacts, such as we or extraterrestrials might make to last for eons.
- Daniel Drezner writes about the ongoing question of what the United States should do in Mali. (Apparently it has to be asked.)
- The Dragon's Tales links to a study suggesting Titan has an active geology, with its carbon sand filling in craters.
- Far Outliers reports on the fine mechanics of racism in colonial Spanish America.
- The Global Sociology Blog notes the many ways in which the Arab Spring does not resemble protests against same-sex marriage in France.
- Marginal Revolution's Tyler Cowen speculates that cultural tourism will be more resilient than scenery-oriented tourism, on account of the limits of the digital world.
- Torontoist reports on the call by a group of Toronto physicians for more bike lanes sooner.
- Window on Eurasia notes that, after the 1969 Sino-Soviet clashes, landmarks on the Russian frontier with China were given new Russian names.
[BLOG] Some Wednesday links
Nov. 14th, 2012 01:11 pm- The Burgh Diaspora's Jim Russell notes how Brazil is using the Afro-Brazilian majority legacy of the transatlantic slave trade to justify the construction of new transatlantic links with Africa.
- Crooked Timber comments upon the Irish anti-abortion laws that just cost a woman her life and the homophobia of the Reagan administration that made HIV/AIDS a laughing matter.
- Daniel Drezner wonders if the ongoing expanding Petraeus scandal will end up diminishing the American public's regard for the military.
- Eastern Approaches notes that no one in the Balkans seems to be commemorating the one hundredth anniversary of the First Balkan War.
- Far Outlier's Joel quotes from Matthew Restall's Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest to describe how Christopher Columbus was really riding on the coat-tails of Portugal's successful long-range maritime exploration.
- Geocurrents observes efforts by some Arab Christians in the Levant to revive Aramaic.
- The Global Sociology Blog reviews Laurent Dubois' Haiti: The Aftershocks of History, highlighting the extent to which Haiti's catastrophes are the products of foreign meddling.
- At Lawyers, Guns and Money, Erik Loomis maps Detroit. The extent to which the borders of the City of Detroit overlap with African-American majority populations, and to which the sprawl of Metro Detroit is constructed so as to detach the suburbs from any responsibility for the city at their region's center, is noteworthy.
- The Planetary Science Blog's Emily Lakdawalla reports on Carl Sagan's feminism.
- The Power and the Money's Noel Maurer summarizes what's going on with Uruguay's decriminalization of marijuana for personal use.
Over at Geocurrents, Nicholas Baldo writes at length about the French heritage of the American Midwest back when it was called the Illinois Country, Le Pays des Illinois.
Once a periphery of French Canada, later becoming thinly-populated "Upper Louisiana", the French heritage of the vast region resisted Anglicization and Americanization much less solidly than that of the modern state of Louisiana at the lower end of the Mississippi. Unlike in Canada and Louisiana, the French fact was just spread too thin to last. Still, as Baldo points out, traces do remain to this day.
Once a periphery of French Canada, later becoming thinly-populated "Upper Louisiana", the French heritage of the vast region resisted Anglicization and Americanization much less solidly than that of the modern state of Louisiana at the lower end of the Mississippi. Unlike in Canada and Louisiana, the French fact was just spread too thin to last. Still, as Baldo points out, traces do remain to this day.
The French presence in Le Pays des Illinois initially centered around the town of Kaskaskia, some fifty miles southeast of present day St. Louis (itself founded by the French forty-three years later). Already a focus of Illinois Indian population, Kaskaskia attracted Jesuit missionaries who established themselves permanently in 1703. Along with the nearby settlements of Prairie du Rocher and Fort de Chartres, Kaskaskia soon boasted perhaps seven thousand French settlers (including women), who lived relatively peacefully alongside the local indigenes. Seven thousand is of course a tiny population by modern standards, but even half that number would have made it one of the largest European settlements in North America at the time. While the French fought viciously against Indian enemies such as the Fox and the Iroquois, the Illinois Indians they lived among shared their diplomatic objectives, and tranquility remained the norm within French and Indian settlements. Intermarriage was common, and resulting mixed-race children were known as métis, a French cognate of the Spanish mestizo.
The French Midwest boomed in the 18th Century not because of the fur trade, but because it was well positioned to supply another growing city to the South: La Nouvelle-Orléans. New Orleans, as the Americans would later call it, became wealthy through shipping and the production of market crops, creating strong demand for wheat and oats from upriver. This new economic geography led to the reassignment of Le Pays des Illinois from Canada to France’s new colony, La Louisiane. The first African slaves arrived in Kaskaskia in 1718, but price ceilings on grains imposed by French officials made the purchase of slaves for farming uneconomical. Instead, many French settlers brought their slaves west to Missouri, where recently discovered lead mines in the Northeastern Ozarks offered a higher rate of return. Canada had barely been settled before the Mississippi became the new focus of French colonization, and now Missouri seemed destined to eclipse Kaskaskia, Prairie du Rocher, and the like in a similar fashion.
Located mainly in Missouri, the Ozark Plateau includes the highest topographical features in North America between the Appalachian Mountains in the East and the Rocky Mountains in the West. Unbeknownst to most, it is also the site of an unbroken French cultural heritage that stretches back some three hundred years. The etymology of the Ozarks is disputed, but most consider it to be a corruption of the French term aux Arks, or, “of Arkansas”. As previously mentioned, it was lead, or, more precisely, galena ore, that brought the French to the region. Missouri sits on the world’s largest deposit of galena, an ore-body that was close enough to the surface to catch the eye of French explorers. Since galena is often found together with silver, the French naturally imagined they had found their answer to Spain’s Cerro de Potosí, the richest silver deposit ever discovered (located in modern Bolivia). Evidence of this enthusiasm lives on to this day in place names like Potosi, Missouri, currently home to some 2,500 people. The miners’ hopes, however, were misplaced. No silver lay under Missouri’s soil, and settlers were left to mine and farm what they could.
La Vieille Mine, anglicized today as Old Mines, Missouri, is perhaps the most impressive example of French culture in the Ozarks region. Statistics are difficult to come by, but according to residents the region around Old Mines may have been home to over a thousand French speakers (known colloquially as “Paw Paw French”) only a few decades ago. Most were middle aged or elderly at the time, so the area’s distinct Missouri French dialect is likely to go extinct before long. Yet the region remains proud of its linguistic heritage. It stages an annual “Missouri French Festival” replete with dance and merriment. Several buildings remain from colonial French times, including a house still in private use.
Andrew Barton just reacted to an article by convicted British felon Conrad Black in National Review, "Post-Colonial Killing Fields", wherein Black defends Western imperialism: "No one could seriously dispute that almost all of sub-Saharan Africa, all of North Africa except Morocco, all of the Middle East except Israel and Jordan and most of the oil-rich states, and the entire former British Indian Empire were better governed by Europeans."
Actually, yes, the case can be made. The various problems that the least-developed colonies had in maintaining functional, prosperous societies speaks to the sustained underinvestment of most colonial powers in their colonies, a sustained underinvestment that was consciously adopted so as to prevent the emergence of social strata that could contest colonial rule. Colonial powers committed numerous sins of omission: Amartya Sen's observation that, for all of its policy failures, independent India has never experienced famines on the scale that regularly hit the British Raj, simply because the Indian government was responsible to its citizens in the way that foreign colonialists never were to their subjects. And, of course, sometimes colonial powers actually did terrible, terrible things to their subjects, the Congo Free State being a prototype but (sadly) not exceptional. The achievements of post-colonial countries were often achieved despite the legacies of past imperialisms.
Barton's conclusion is worth sharing.
Actually, yes, the case can be made. The various problems that the least-developed colonies had in maintaining functional, prosperous societies speaks to the sustained underinvestment of most colonial powers in their colonies, a sustained underinvestment that was consciously adopted so as to prevent the emergence of social strata that could contest colonial rule. Colonial powers committed numerous sins of omission: Amartya Sen's observation that, for all of its policy failures, independent India has never experienced famines on the scale that regularly hit the British Raj, simply because the Indian government was responsible to its citizens in the way that foreign colonialists never were to their subjects. And, of course, sometimes colonial powers actually did terrible, terrible things to their subjects, the Congo Free State being a prototype but (sadly) not exceptional. The achievements of post-colonial countries were often achieved despite the legacies of past imperialisms.
Barton's conclusion is worth sharing.
Let me sum this up real quickly, here: modern states that were European colonies were not better off when they were European colonies, and there's a simple reason for it that goes beyond the lack of representation, the oppression, and general exploitation. European colonies were run for the benefit of the colonial master, not the colonies themselves - if a certain thing improved the lot of a colony, it would be because the ruling colonial power believed it to be in its own best interest. Choice is sacred, self-determination is vital, and the colonies of Europe had neither.
[BLOG] Some Wednesday links
May. 30th, 2012 02:53 pm- Andrew Barton at Acts of Minor Treason wonders about the next generation of birthers, concerned with "natural-born" presidential candidates: what of the genetically engineered?
- blogTO notes that People's Foods, an iconic diner in The Annex on Dupont Street, is closing down due to rising rents.
- Far Outliers profiles the displacement of classical Chinese as the written language of Vietnam by Latin-script Vietnamese under the French.
- Geocurrents observes that Eurovision's second-place winners, Russia's Buranovskie Babushki, come from the pagan-inflected Finnic republic of Udmurtia.
- At Lawyers, Guns and Money, Erik Loomis provides a sympathetic review of the Earth Liberation Front and the documentary If A Tree Falls.
- Language Log notes the controversy in Ukraine regarding the introduction of Russian as an official language.
- Open the Future's Jamais Cascio blogs about his impressions of Kazakstan's new capital Astana--being built practically overnight in the middle of the steppe--and an economic conference being held there that's curiously tone-deaf.
- Torontoist noted that red-paned Toronto skyscraper Scotia Plaza has been sold for a cool $C 1.27 billion.
- Zero Geography's Mark Graham compares English- and French-language geotagged articles on Wikipedia and finds with the exception of France, the Maghreb, and selected points elsewhere, English outnumbers French.
[ISL] "Is the Chamorro language dead?"
Apr. 10th, 2012 12:24 pmJohn S. DelRosario Jr.'s column in the Saipan Tribune is an interesting artifact from a society about to experience the death of its traditional language.
Saipan is the largest island of the United States' self-governing Micronesian commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands. Chamorro is a language of the Austronesian family distantly related to--among the better-known Austronesian languages--Filipino, Bahasa Indonesia, and Malagasy.
The Northern Marianas Island, along with adjacent Guam, has been under colonial rule for centuries--Spanish, Japanese, American. In the most recent century, any number of factors centering around the disruption of traditional societies by globalization has led to a full-fledged shift away from Chamorro towards English. In this article, DelRosario talks about his decision to stop writing a newspaper column in Chamorro.
The implications of this for identity in this part of Micronesia, especially given the heavy influences of colonial powers on what's now identified as "traditional" culture, is examined at length.
Go, read.
Saipan is the largest island of the United States' self-governing Micronesian commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands. Chamorro is a language of the Austronesian family distantly related to--among the better-known Austronesian languages--Filipino, Bahasa Indonesia, and Malagasy.
The Northern Marianas Island, along with adjacent Guam, has been under colonial rule for centuries--Spanish, Japanese, American. In the most recent century, any number of factors centering around the disruption of traditional societies by globalization has led to a full-fledged shift away from Chamorro towards English. In this article, DelRosario talks about his decision to stop writing a newspaper column in Chamorro.
Like dry leaf bouncing erratically in the open waters, someday it would soak and sink to the bottom of the sea, never to be seen again. Sadly, this is how I see the demise of our native tongue. Up ahead, our children would see the loss of something intrinsically valuable as it recedes with the tide of neglect, so mutilated by the demands of modernity.
[. . .]
Understandably, folks have related how hard it is to read in their lingo. Indeed, it is humiliating! But many of us are victims of an educational system that teaches English as we move from grammar to high school. We developed literacy in English while we devolve into illiteracy in our own native tongue. It’s nobody’s fault. But look at the long-term effects of illiteracy in our own language. It’s our last hope to perpetuating our peoplehood, isn’t it?
I learned my Chamorro in the first and second grades. Learning the written aspect of it never waned in spite of the instructional discontinuation. I have struggled during the initial years of penning my thoughts to ensure some appreciable measure of being conversant on issues, written with clarity. It became a lot easier with constant writing exercises through the years. It felt good, though I still refuse to use the orthography from Guam. It isn’t representative of the Chamorro taught then nor is it anywhere near what the learned folks have shared and conveyed to us before moving on.
The decision to bury my written column in the vernacular is founded in the assessment that hardly anybody reads Chamorro these days. Specifically, I quiz if I’ve done justice in the use of the written Chamorro or did I exact the complete opposite-discouraged more than encouraged its use. It seems an issue often treated with the adage, "After all is said and done, a lot more is said than done." And unless there’s strong and wide support of encouragement to continue, it ends on the last week of April.
It is this sad assessment plus 40 years of walking up to the loneliest mound on earth that hastened ending this journey this year. I will prepare an obituary for it. It seems a useless journey I liken to the narrowing of the arteries. Eventually, it loses its use and function. But I think I’ve conquered my dream of writing in my vernacular. Thank God it came with the love of writing and tons of inspiration. To write successfully is to write. Proficiency comes with the routine and critical review or reasoning. Nothing else! That I will end my written Chamorro will not change, in any form or fashion, my being Chamorro.
The implications of this for identity in this part of Micronesia, especially given the heavy influences of colonial powers on what's now identified as "traditional" culture, is examined at length.
Go, read.
Joe. My. God. linked to an excerpt (published in the Washington Post of Craig Timberg and Daniel Halperin's new book Tinderbox, one of several books recently published which draw upon molecular biology and history to describe how HIV became a global pandemic with tens of millions of dead and infected when a century ago it was limited to chimpanzee populations in central Africa. Colonialism--specifically, the demand for ivory in southeastern Cameroon where HIV-infected chimpanzees lived, a century ago udner German control--is responsible for the shift.
I'll be looking out for Tinderbox when it comes out. It'll be worth comparing it with Jacques Pepin's The Origins of AIDS, which I blogged about at Demography Matters back in December. Pepin's narrative places greater importance on medical campaigns--specifically, the use of unsterile needles in campaigns against sleeping sickness in French Equatorial Africa--in letting HIV infect enough people to create the critical mass necessary for a global epidemic.
Clearly, though, the two books share a common emphasis on the misdeeds, knowing and otherwise, of colonial empires in central Africa. That's enough for a first approximation.
Not far from where HIV-1 group M was born was a major river, the Sangha, flowing toward the heart of Central Africa. This section of the Sangha was not ideal for navigation because of its ribbons of sandbars and the dense vegetation along its banks.
In the especially treacherous middle section, near where Hahn and Sharp’s team found the viral ancestor of HIV, few major human settlements ever developed. But there were numerous communities on the Sangha’s more accessible stretches. And due south, past riverside trading towns, was the mighty Congo River itself, the superhighway of Central Africa.
[. . .]
In December 1895 German colonial authorities heard reports that Cameroon’s southeastern corner contained fabulously rich ivory and rubber stocks awaiting exploitation.
The Germans soon after gave authority to a colonial company to take control of the region by force. Over the next four years they extended their power all the way through southeastern Cameroon and established a trading station on the Ngoko River about 75 miles upstream from where its waters merged with the Sangha. In the wedge of land defined by these two rivers, HIV either had just been born or soon would be.
The trading station was called Moloundou, and a busy town remains there today. But at the time it was almost unimaginably remote. Few human settlements had developed among these forbidding forests. And there were only two practical ways out: by steamship down the Ngoko to the Sangha and on to the Congo River; or overland by foot to the Atlantic.
The river route was the easier of the two, and steamships transported the bulk of the ivory and rubber collected in southeastern Cameroon. But overland routes were necessary to connect Moloundou with other trading stations and inland areas rich with rubber and ivory.
[. . .]
In just a few years [syphillis] reached epidemic proportions along porter routes and riverside trading posts in Cameroon and throughout the Congo Basin. It’s impossible now to determine how much of this spread resulted from rapes as opposed to other kinds of encounters, but it’s clear that colonial commerce created massive new networks of sexual interactions — and massive new transmissions of infections. (In later decades, transmission through the reuse of hypodermic needles in medical care probably had some role in HIV’s spread as well.)
So HIV’s first journey looked something like this: A hunter killed an infected chimp in the southeastern Cameroonian forest, and a simian virus entered his body through a cut during the butchering, mutating into HIV.
This probably had happened many times before, during the centuries when the region had little contact with the outside world. But now thousands of porters — both men and women — were crossing through the area regularly, creating more opportunities for the virus to travel onward to a riverside trading station such as Moloundou.
One of the first victims — whether a hunter, a porter or an ivory collector — gave HIV to a sexual partner. There may have been a small outbreak around the trading station before the virus found its way aboard a steamship headed down the Sangha River.
[. . .]
Most of this colonial world didn’t have enough potential victims for such a fragile virus to start a major epidemic. HIV is harder to transmit than many other infections. People can have sex hundreds of times without passing the virus on. To spread widely, HIV requires a population large enough to sustain an outbreak and a sexual culture in which people often have more than one partner, creating networks of interaction that propel the virus onward.
To fulfill its grim destiny, HIV needed a kind of place never before seen in Central Africa but one that now was rising in the heart of the region: a big, thriving, hectic place jammed with people and energy, where old rules were cast aside amid the tumult of new commerce.
It needed Kinshasa. It was here, hundreds of miles downriver from Cameroon, that HIV began to grow beyond a mere outbreak. It was here that AIDS grew into an epidemic.
I'll be looking out for Tinderbox when it comes out. It'll be worth comparing it with Jacques Pepin's The Origins of AIDS, which I blogged about at Demography Matters back in December. Pepin's narrative places greater importance on medical campaigns--specifically, the use of unsterile needles in campaigns against sleeping sickness in French Equatorial Africa--in letting HIV infect enough people to create the critical mass necessary for a global epidemic.
Clearly, though, the two books share a common emphasis on the misdeeds, knowing and otherwise, of colonial empires in central Africa. That's enough for a first approximation.